View Single Post
Old March 27th, 2016 #11
Karl Radl
The Epitome of Evil
 
Karl Radl's Avatar
 
Join Date: Aug 2007
Location: The Unseen University of New York
Posts: 3,130
Default

Holocaust Survivor Stories

(Week Ending 27/03/2016)


To touch off this week we have the amusing news that jews in the Netherlands are loudly kvetching about an Anne Frank themed escape room. Oy, gevalt the memory of the 'Holocaust' is sacred and only jews are allowed to use their personally copyrighted brand of victim hood!

We've also had the news that in Markowa, Poland: a new 'Holocaust museum' has opened. (2) Although like the prototypical Social Justice Warriors that they are: this is never enough for the jews. Since, as the Jerusalem Post opines, Poland must do more lest it be judged to be not sorry enough for alleged atrocities it and its citizen had little to do with. (3)

Speaking of atrocities it has also been revealed this week that the United States government is to fund the lives of forty 'Holocaust Survivors' and fund the kosher meals of twenty-three more in California at cost of twelve million dollars over five years. (4)

So why is the US taxpayer paying millions of dollars for sixty- so-called victims of an event seventy years ago that had little if anything to do with it.

Meanwhile in Florida the local rag, the 'Sun Sentinel', has been angrily denouncing the US State Department for not getting the sixty million dollars paid by the French national railway company SNCF as 'Holocaust reparations' to the 'needy local Holocaust survivors'. (5) Apparently the 'Sun Sentinel' has forgotten that hundreds of millions of dollars have been squandered in various different bouts of corruption and fraud by jewish 'Holocaust Reparations' organizations (6) and that the US state department being a bit bureaucratic over sixty million dollars is hardly anything in the scene of things.

Nothing like getting your priorities right!

However I suppose there are different rules for jews and non-jews in the 'Sun Sentinel's' eyes...

Now lets move from general 'Holocaust' news to some of the 'Holocaust Survivor' stories in the news this week.

First off we find one Magda Brown detailing her story at Ohlone College in California.

I quote:

'It is Magda Brown’s story, and the 88-year old survivor of one of World War II’s darkest moments came to Ohlone’s Smith Center on Thursday night to share her experiences, personal tragedies, and how she survived Auschwitz, one of Germany’s concentration camps, in the hopes of reminding students of the horrors she and others endured so that they are never repeated.

She witnessed the eventual breakdown of her rights, and the rights of all Jews living in Hungary, as they were stripped of jobs, property and personal belongings, and forced to march into ghettos, where they would live until they were eventually piled into cramped trains and sent to concentration camps.

Brown and her family were sent to Auschwitz on June 11, 1944, just days after the allied invasion of Normandy and on Brown’s 17th birthday. She endured a three-day train ride in which she had to remain standing all three days because of the cramped train cars, and suffered through dehydration along with those in the train car with her.

“You cannot fathom – I won’t even wish it on my worst enemy on this earth – to go for three days without any water,” she said.

Upon entering Auschwitz, the Nazi guards at the camp separated Brown from her family as they divided the men from the women, and later from her mother.

Brown told her mother that she would see her later.

“Unfortunately, later never comes,” she said.

It later dawned on Brown that her mother was sent to be killed as part of Adolf Hitler’s “Final Solution,” which resulted in the deaths of millions of Jewish people under Nazi Germany’s orders.

Brown then spoke about surviving the cruel conditions of Auschwitz, having to fend for herself without her family.' (7)

Right so if we pare all this down to what Brown is actually saying it is as follows.

A) She was a presumably malnourished (i.e. 'cruel conditions') sixteen year old girl in Auschwitz.

B) She was separated from her mother and never saw her again.

These are probable enough statements, but we should notice two things in regard to them.

In the first instance we should note that at no point does Brown even consider the fact that in mid-1944 the Third Reich was in a dire predicament. It barely had enough food to feed everyone in its territory. Why on earth does Brown seek to necessarily imply that the 'cruel conditions' were specific to her and her jews rather than everyone within the Third Reich's territory as was actually was the case?

Well other than to make the 'evil Nazis' seem even more proverbially satanic I guess.

In the second instance just because Brown was separated from her mother and never saw her again in Auschwitz does not mean – even if you believe the orthodox narrative – that Brown's mother was murdered in a homicidal gas chamber.

We don't know how Brown's mother died at Auschwitz, whether she survived the camp and died elsewhere or after the war. We simply don't know and nor apparently does Brown.

It is absolute drivel to claim someone was killed in a specific way when you have no proof or actual reason to assume this other than 'she was in Auschwitz'.

Brown's story gets even weirder when she narrates her escape from German captivity thus:

'She befriended a trio of sisters in the camp, and when the Germans marched them out of Auschwitz toward the end of World War II, they made a daring, desperate escape attempt to hide in a barn under cover of night. They were later discovered by American soldiers, who liberated them from Nazi captivity.' (8)

Right except the problem with this claim is that presumably Brown hid in said barn as soon as possible on her march to western Germany from south-western Poland. After all the claim is that the SS guards were murdering those who fell behind or had trouble walking (9) and malnourished teenage girls would have likely have had issues with this kind of prolonged physical activity.

In other words Brown and her girlfriends would have had to escape to a barn fairly quickly on their route, which likely places them in eastern Germany sometime in mid to late 1944. This in turn makes it extremely unlikely that they would have been 'discovered' by American soldiers (who didn't get into eastern/central Germany for several months) but rather by the advancing Red Army.

Therefore it is easy to see that Brown's story just... well... doesn't make a whole lot of sense.

This in turn makes it even more amusing when she states:

'At the end of her lecture, Brown urged the audience to protect their freedom, to think before they hate, and to stand up to skeptics and deniers of the Holocaust.' (10)

So she can't even get her story straight, but she apparently wants people 'protect their freedom' from skeptics and critics of her alleged victim status

In other words: Brown wants to protect freedom by curtailing freedom.

Not too much of an Orwellian non-sequitur there!

Next we have 'Holocaust Survivor' Pinchas Gutter who has been speaking in Winnipeg this week. Take it away Pinchas:

'Toronto Holocaust survivor Pinchas Gutter is scheduled to be the keynote speaker at Winnipeg’s annual high school Holocaust symposium, which is being held two months earlier than usual this year in an effort to attract more students.

Gutter, a child survivor of the Warsaw Ghetto and several concentration camps, is slated to speak March 17 at the Freeman Family Foundation Holocaust Education Centre of the Jewish Heritage Centre of Western Canada’s 15th Holocaust and Human Rights Symposium for students in grades 9 to 12.

Gutter – whom Jarniewski called “an extraordinary individual” – was born into a family that can trace its roots back 400 years in Poland. Originally from Lodz, he was seven years old when the war broke out. He and his family lived in the Warsaw Ghetto for 3-1⁄2 years until April 1943, the time of the ghetto uprising. They were deported to the Majdanek death camp, where the rest of Gutter’s family was murdered. He survived six concentration camps and a death march toward the end of the war. Russian forces liberated him in May 1945, and, under the auspices of the United Nations, he was taken to Britain with other children for rehabilitation. After spending many years in South Africa, he immigrated to Canada.' (11)

Right so Gutter claims to have survived the Lodz Ghetto, Majdanek death camp, six unspecified concentration camps and a death march.

So... that is sort of improbable especially if the Germans were allegedly covering their tracks in 1944 and with Gutter having gone through so many of the facilities allegedly killing jews by gassing or starvation. He would be a prime candidate to be eliminated. So why didn't the SS simply shoot him to cover up their alleged crimes? Did they forget? Let him off? Make a bureaucratic mistake or what?

The simplest reason for this is because Madjanek wasn't actually a death camp, there was no German plan to mass murder jewish people and the 'death march' was simply the evacuation of all prisoners – jews and non-jews - away from the well-known and god-awful behaviour of Stalin's advancing Red Army.

Otherwise quite frankly Gutter's story is about plausible and likely as the pedal-powered brain-bashing machines that were claimed to have been in used by the SS to kill jews.

Next we have Joseph Sher who died recently in New Orleans. Sher's story is related as follows:

'A native of Kzepice, Poland, Mr. Sher was sent during World War II to a series of German-run slave-labor camps, where he and other Jewish men were put to work building roads. It was grueling, his son Leopold Sher said, and many members of the crew perished from disease or were shot dead by the guards. Out of 1,000 men who set out on this detail, only three returned alive, Mr. Sher said in an oral history interview.' (12)

Right... so, as the article describes it, Sher worked build roads in the freezing cold for the Germans. That makes sense as it is a work detail and fits with the historical narrative, but what doesn't is the idea that 'three out a thousand men' who were used as convict labour to build roads survived the experience.

In the first instance it isn't freezing cold for most of year and as Sher relates elsewhere in the article: the prisoners slept in the warm hay in farmer's barns (presumably along with their guards). Not exactly White Sea Canal 'extermination by labour' conditions.

In the second the Third Reich desperately needed labour so it had little logical reason to desire to reduce its own labour force. After all Sher's job would have had to have been done by someone else if he and his friends were to be killed off.

Sher's claim just doesn't make an awful of sense, which is backed up by the fact that it is a claim made decades after the events described to an oral history project. It isn't one backed up by documents (which there must surely have been or still exist somewhere), but rather is simply Sher making unsubstantiated claims about dimly-remembered events that occurred decades ago.

Next we have Martin Judovitz in Florida. His story is briefly described as follows by the 'Sun Sentinel':

'Martin Judovitz, 90, of Boca Raton, hoped that by hearing specific instances of anti-Semitism, students would stop future persecution.

"I was riding a train and six soldiers were making fun of me and throwing me around like a football," he said, recalling Hungary in 1942.

Judovitz, who was separated from his family at the death camp Auschwitz, said he has spent his life after the war searching for his sister. "I've looked for them all these years and never found them," he said.' (13)

So first off Judovitz claims six Hungarian soldiers were 'throwing him around like a football' on a train in 1942. Except by my reckoning Judovitz was 15 or 16 years old at the time not 5 or 6. So how on earth were said soldiers 'throwing him around like a football' in a train?

What was Judovitz? A dwarf? Were these Hungarian soldiers bodybuilders or what?

Also I note that once again, as with Magda Brown's story, there is absolutely no reason for Judovitz to assume that because he last saw his family in Auschwitz. That they were therefore killed there via the use of homicidal gas chambers as he necessarily implies. Judovitz doesn't even know that they did die in Auschwitz: he just seems to assume without reasonable cause that they did.

Henry Reich meanwhile seems to have taken a leaf out of Pinchas Gutter's book and claims to have been another miraculous 'Holocaust Survivor'. One sort of wonders where on earth all these 'miracles' came from or why they seem to have happened all at once and only to jews between 1939 and 1945, but anyway.

Reich's story is briefly described as follows:

'Henry Reich, 90, of Boca Raton, survived the Warsaw Ghetto Uprising and seven concentration camps. He said he routinely tells his story because "the world should know what happened."' (14)

Okay... so let me get this straight. Reich claims he survived an armed urban popular uprising against experienced military and anti-partisan forces, survived the vengeful aftermath of said uprising and then also survived six concentration camps where the same people were allegedly looking for any excuse to kill him on the spot.

Why you wouldn't believe that Henry Reich is telling you the truth?

It's not like it is a little far fetched or anything!

Norman Frajman, also of Florida, fares even less well in the plausibility of the account. Since he manages to 'deny the Holocaust' while 'teaching people about it'. To wit:

'When Frajman was 10, German troops stormed his town and locked his family in the Warsaw Ghetto. His mother and sister were murdered, and at age 12, Frajman was sent alone to a concentration camp.

"I was just a child," he said. "And you know what my crime was? I was born to the Jewish faith."

Frajman was forced from camp to camp until the Russian Army liberated him during the death march in Germany.

He shared his story while clutching a striped jacket issued to him by Nazis at a concentration camp in 1944.

"It was with me all this time, and it was really a witness to all the atrocities," he said. "It's a jacket, but it's my jacket."' (15)

Now isn't his 'clutching of a striped jacket' just so cute?

Well regardless of that Frajman claims to have been put in a concentration camp aged twelve, but yet he would have been a child and probably a slightly malnourished one. Guess what should have been done to Frajman as a child according to 'Holocaust' orthodoxy?

That's right: he should have been transported to the gas chambers for immediate extermination.

Whoopsy daisy!

To round off this week we have Stephanie Marks who fled to the United States early in the war (16) and Fred Gross whose family fled France in 1940. (17) Clearly they had some kind of extra-sensory abilities enabling them to predict the future and are considered 'Holocaust Survivors' even though the 'Holocaust' was not even allegedly thought off as a policy until after Marks and Gross fled continental Europe!


References


(1) http://news.nationalpost.com/news/wo...-the-holocaust
(2) http://www.wboc.com/story/31497077/n...-in-holocaust; http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7...780126,00.html
(3) http://www.jpost.com/Breaking-News/P...entiles-448408
(4) http://patch.com/california/san-dieg...rvivor-cars-0; http://www.jweekly.com/article/full/...m-former-ussr/
(5) http://www.sun-sentinel.com/opinion/...317-story.html
(6) For two quick examples: https://www.fbi.gov/newyork/press-re...zi-persecution & http://www.theblaze.com/stories/2010...ve-fraud-case/
(7) http://ohlonemonitor.com/news/2016/0....fWL7toFd.dpuf
(8) Ibid.
(9) http://www.wollheim-memorial.de/en/r...er_todesmarsch
(10) http://ohlonemonitor.com/news/2016/0....fWL7toFd.dpuf
(11) http://www.cjnews.com/news/canada/hi...nual-symposium
(12) http://www.nola.com/business/index.s...st_surviv.html
(13) http://www.sun-sentinel.com/local/pa...318-story.html
(14) Ibid.
(15) Ibid.
(16) http://www.cincinnati.com/story/news...fter/81808718/
(17) http://www.wkyt.com/content/news/Hol...372597362.html

-----------------------------

This was originally published at the following address: http://www.semiticcontroversies.blog...r-stories.html
__________________