Full Thread: New Zealand
View Single Post
Old December 31st, 2009 #31
America First
Senior Member
 
America First's Avatar
 
Join Date: Jul 2005
Location: Earth
Posts: 3,699
Default

[quote=D. Fitzgerald;835724]Racism claim over cannibal book
4:00AM Wednesday August 27, 2008
By Yvonne Tahana


Paul Moon is saddened that someone has made a complaint of racism over his book This Horrid Practice.

A study of Maori cannibalism by historian Paul Moon has prompted a racism complaint to the Human Rights Commission.

Sent anonymously to Dr Moon, the complaint said This Horrid Practice "describes the whole of Maori society as violent and dangerous. This is a clearly racist view claiming a whole ethnic group has these traits".

The commission has taken no action on it yet but a spokesperson said yesterday any mediation would occur in confidence and the complainant's name would not be released.

The commission said books and publications were covered by the Human Rights Act, however there was a high threshold that had to be met to prevent unwarranted incursion into the right to freedom of expression.

Released in August, the book posits that consuming vanquished enemies' mana had little to do with the underlying reason for Maori cannibalism. Instead cannibalism, in pre-colonial times, was simply about "rage and humiliation".

Dr Moon said he was disappointed that a complaint had been made.


"I spent several years researching this book, using an enormous body of documentation, and I am not about to denounce it just because it upsets a few people.

"What I am saying is, I approach things honestly and apply standard methods of research to it. If anyone disagrees that's fine. But there are ways of disagreeing, making a complaint about a person isn't the way.

"I think it's just very sad that it's come to this stage that when you write about certain topics in New Zealand history you get complaints and accusations of racism levelled at you."

The book has received mixed reviews within Maoridom. Canterbury University's Rawiri Taonui is a severe critic. He called the book an example of "poor scholarship" which "demonises"%
__________________
Isn't it strange that we talk least about the things we think about most?

We cannot allow the natural passions and prejudices of other peoples
to lead our country to destruction.

-Charles A. Lindbergh
http://www.fff.org/freedom/0495c.asp